Automatic or Manual? Choosing a 4x4 Transmission for Iceland
Automatic or manual 4x4 for Iceland? Compare comfort, driving conditions, F-roads and rental costs to choose the best transmission for your Iceland adventure.
The gearbox is one of the first choices you make when booking a 4x4 for Iceland. It’s also one of the easiest to make on autopilot. For most travellers, picking what they drive at home is the right call, but a few details about our fleet and Iceland's roads are worth knowing first.
Below, we look at where the choice makes a difference on Iceland's roads, and where it barely matters.

Does It Matter If You Rent an Automatic or Manual 4x4 in Iceland?
When visiting Iceland, your choice of gearbox doesn’t affect which roads you can drive, but rather how relaxed you feel behind the wheel.
What makes it feel like a bigger decision here is the first day: you may be tired after the flight and still getting used to the car, so it helps to have one less thing to think about. That's why the question has less to do with Iceland and more to do with what you drive at home.
Where you can go is a separate question, and it depends on the vehicle. Regardless of gearbox, our 4x4s that are approved for F-roads can be driven on every F-road (the unpaved mountain roads into the Highlands, open only in summer) except F249 to Þórsmörk.
That said, not every model suits every Highland route. Our guide on whether you need a 4x4 in Iceland explains how to match the vehicle to your route. For a side-by-side look at the main car types, see how to choose the right rental car in Iceland.
Which Gearbox Suits Your Trip to Iceland?
Before choosing the transmission for your Iceland car rental, consider what you're most comfortable driving and the kind of trip you have in mind.
Why Choose an Automatic?
At Icerental 4x4, the majority of our range is automatic. An automatic has several advantages on an Icelandic road trip, even for drivers who are happy with either gearbox. Long driving days are less tiring without a clutch to work, and on exposed stretches where crosswinds gust, it helps to keep both hands on the wheel rather than reaching for the gear lever.
Our automatic range runs from compact SUVs such as the Subaru XV and Suzuki Vitara up to the Toyota RAV4 and Ford Kuga, and the automatic roof-tent campers include the Maxus T-60 pickup.

When Does a Manual Make Sense?
For a confident manual driver, the real question is whether one of our two manual models suits your trip. Choosing a manual narrows you to the Dacia Duster, which seats five, or the compact Suzuki Jimny. Both also come as roof-tent campers.
Don't pick a manual purely to save money, though: in our range the price gap between the manual Duster and the cheapest automatics is usually small.
The Jimny also has low range, a lower set of gears in its 4WD system that gives extra pulling power at walking pace on steep, loose ground. Most compact SUVs don't, which makes this small manual unusually capable on rough tracks.
If you're used to driving on the left in the UK, Ireland or Australia, there's one extra thing to bear in mind: you'll change gear with your right hand while adjusting to the other side of the road. It's easy enough to get used to, but if you'd rather keep things simple, an automatic takes that job away.

How Do Automatic and Manual 4x4s Compare on Iceland's Roads?
On most of Iceland's roads, either gearbox works well. The differences appear where the surface changes or the gradient steepens, and they mostly come down to picking the right gear at the right moment.
Our overview of Iceland's road system and conditions explains in more detail what each road type is like to drive.
On the Ring Road
The Route 1 Ring Road loops around the whole country for more than 1,300 km (800 miles), linking Reykjavík with almost every region and many of the sights first-time visitors come to see. It's paved all the way and mostly one lane in each direction, so either gearbox is at home. The limit on rural paved stretches is 90 km/h (56 mph), though weather and road conditions often call for less.
On parts of the route, especially in the south-east, you'll slow for single-lane bridges, where the vehicle closest to the bridge has priority, so be ready to stop if someone is already approaching. With a manual, you drop a gear early. With an automatic, you ease off and let the gearbox follow. Our Ring Road guide covers the route in detail.
On Gravel and Mountain Roads
Side roads in Iceland can switch from asphalt to gravel with little warning, and on gravel the limit drops to 80 km/h (50 mph). If your route crosses mountain passes in the Eastfjords or Westfjords, the long descents are where technique matters most.
In a manual, a lower gear lets the engine hold your speed. In an automatic, use the manual mode or the L setting to do the same job, so you aren't riding the brakes all the way down.
On F-Roads
As for Iceland's F-roads, both gearboxes cope well, as long as you pick a low gear early and keep a steady speed. On steep, loose climbs, pick your gear at the bottom, not halfway up. Check how demanding your route is in our guide to F-roads in Iceland before you set off.
Permission to drive an F-road is also separate from insurance: none of our insurance packages covers damage on F-roads. The optional roadside assistance waiver covers rescue if you get stuck, but not damage to the car, so check what your insurance covers before planning a Highland route.
At River Crossings
At a river, pick a low gear before you enter the water and don't change it until you're out the other side. In a manual, that means choosing a low gear and keeping the revs steady so the engine doesn't stall halfway across. In an automatic, that means using low or manual mode, which varies by model, so ask our team to show you how it works when you collect the car.
None of our insurance packages covers water damage from river crossings, so if you're unsure about a river, don't cross it. Our river crossing guide explains how to judge depth and current.

Does Transmission Matter for Winter Driving in Iceland?
During the winter season, which in Iceland runs from 1 November to 15 April, all our vehicles come with winter tyres, and those tyres, together with your speed, do more for grip than the gearbox ever will.
Where your choice of gearbox does show is when pulling away on ice. In a manual, starting in second gear can help, because it sends less power to the wheels and reduces wheelspin. Many automatics deliver power smoothly to begin with, and some models have a snow or winter mode that does a similar job.
Whatever you drive, keep your inputs gentle: brake early and steer without sudden movements. On the day you travel, check the forecast on vedur.is, road conditions on umferdin.is and any alerts on safetravel.is. Our guide to driving in Iceland covers winter conditions in more depth.
What to Check When You Collect the Car
When you reach our office in Reykjanesbær, ask the team to walk you through the controls before you set off. That means the gear selector, the parking brake (electronic on many newer cars) and how to engage 4WD. On the Jimny, the 4WD lever is worth a quick demonstration.
Then spend five minutes in the car park. Pull away, stop and reverse a few times, so everything feels familiar by the time you reach the main road.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can I drive a manual in Iceland if my licence is automatic only?
If your licence carries restriction code 78, which appears on licences restricted to automatic vehicles, that restriction still applies in Iceland. You also can't be added as a second driver on a manual rental, which matters if you plan to share the driving. Our team checks every licence for restriction codes when you collect the car, so if yours carries one, book an automatic from the start.
- Is every AWD vehicle allowed on F-roads?
AWD describes how a car drives its wheels, not whether it's approved for F-roads. Our Suzuki Vitara and Toyota RAV4 are AWD and permitted, while the electric Cadillac Lyriq is AWD but not. Check the F-road status on each vehicle page before you plan a Highland route.
- Does an automatic 4x4 use more fuel than a manual?
That depends more on the model than on the gearbox. Manuals used to have a clear edge, but modern automatics have closed most of the gap, so if fuel costs matter, compare the consumption figures for the specific models you're considering.
Ready to Hit the Road?
Once the gearbox is settled, it's one less thing on your mind, and your attention can switch to where it belongs: on the black-sand beaches of the south coast or, in summer, the striped rhyolite mountains at the end of the road to Landmannalaugar.
Compare the models and book your 4x4 rental, and our team will be waiting for you in the arrivals hall at Keflavík.